Listing opportunities series, part 3 of 7
A short sale is a sale where the price won’t cover what’s owed, so the lender has to agree to take less. Being behind on payments doesn’t mean that’s the case, so check the home’s value, the real payoff, other liens and selling costs before anyone uses the word.
Being in default and needing a short sale aren’t the same thing. Default means a loan obligation hasn’t been met, usually missed payments. A short sale only comes into it when the sale won’t bring in enough to pay off the mortgage (or another claim) and the creditor would have to agree to take less. An owner can be months behind and still have enough equity to sell and pay everything. Another owner can look like they have plenty of equity until someone looks closely at the condition, the payoff and the costs.
Both situations come up in KW Default Solutions (KWDS) training. For the local agent, the skill isn’t deciding which one it is on day one. It’s knowing what has to be checked before anyone decides.
First, make sure selling is what they want to look at
People reach out because they’re worried, not always because they’ve decided to move. If the owner wants to keep the house, payment help and retention options are conversations with their servicer and with a housing counselor or attorney, and your ability to estimate a sale price doesn’t replace any of that.
If they do want to look at selling, you can help figure out whether a realistic sale covers what’s owed and what it costs to sell. That starts with the house, not the mortgage statement.
The value has to be the house as it is
A renovated house down the street selling well doesn’t set the value for one with an unresolved leak, missing appliances or a busier location. Use comparable sales and current competition that actually match, explain the differences and say what you couldn’t verify. A condition problem can shrink the buyer pool and affect financing, not just the price.
You don’t have to diagnose a foundation or a roof to note that it needs to be looked at. What you do have to avoid is treating the optimistic number as the value just because it leaves more equity on the worksheet.
The statement balance isn’t the payoff
The balance on a mortgage statement and the amount it takes to pay the loan off at closing can be different. Interest and fees can add to it, and a payoff quote is usually good through a specific date.
Then there’s everything else that may need to be paid at closing: a second mortgage or home equity line, unpaid property taxes, HOA dues or other liens (legal claims against the property). Ask who is getting current figures through the authorized process and who is reviewing title, and don’t assume there’s nothing else because the owner only mentioned one loan. After that, add the actual costs of selling under the agreements on this file. Commission is negotiable, and nothing in this exercise assumes a standard rate.
The same house, three prices
Fictional example: these numbers are for teaching, not a real file and not typical costs.
Say the house is expected to sell for $300,000. The first mortgage payoff is $225,000, a second lien is $15,000 and estimated selling and closing costs are $24,000. If you only look at the price and the first mortgage, it looks like $75,000 of room. Once you add the second lien and the costs, it’s $36,000, which may support an equity sale once the figures are confirmed.
Now say the comps and the condition only support $270,000. Holding everything else the same, that leaves $6,000, which is a thin cushion if the payoff goes up, another lien turns up or a buyer asks for a repair credit.
At $260,000, the same math comes out $4,000 short. That shortfall needs review, but it doesn’t prove a lender will approve a short sale, and it doesn’t mean the owner has no other options.
(In a real file some costs move with the price, so you’d rework the whole worksheet instead of holding things constant. The point is just that the first mortgage balance alone tells you very little.)
Money and time are two different questions
A sale can work on paper and still run out of time. If the owner has received a notice or mentions a sale date, find out who will verify it and get the right professional involved. Don’t estimate how much time is left from another state’s process or another homeowner’s story.
A listing agreement, a purchase contract or a short sale package doesn’t, by itself, stop a foreclosure, and having equity doesn’t buy extra time either. The owner needs both answers: whether the numbers appear to work, and whether the sale can actually close under the circumstances that apply to them.
If it might come up short, say what happens next
Something like this is honest and useful: “Based on the current estimates, the sale may not cover everything that’s owed. We need to confirm those figures and have the right people review whether a short sale or another option makes sense.”
That’s a lot better than “you’ll qualify for a short sale” when nobody has asked the lender anything. Be clear about who is authorized to talk to the creditor, what documents they’ll need and which approvals the sale depends on. Questions about taxes or credit go to the right professionals, and the agent shouldn’t promise that selling settles every obligation.
Deficiency is its own question. Whether a lender can come after a homeowner for what’s left after a short sale or foreclosure is governed by state law, and the rules differ a lot from state to state. Check your state’s rules with a local real estate attorney before you talk about it, and don’t borrow an answer from another state or another agent’s file.
On your next property review, try marking every figure on the worksheet as verified, estimated or missing, with a name next to each missing one. A tidy calculation built on unverified numbers can still send a homeowner in the wrong direction.
Previous: The homeowner already talked to our team. Now it’s your call.
Next: The local agent’s job on a corporate or investor listing